You know this story.
A young Black woman in Montgomery, Alabama, in 1955, refused to give up her seat on a public bus and was arrested for her refusal. But there’s much more to her story than you may realize.
You see, we sometimes forget that the United States was a racially segregated nation within living memory. I have a memory from when I was about 4 years old of going into the “wrong” restroom at a bus station–I went into the “colored” restroom and was gently escorted out and shown the “mens” room by a nice person inside. Black Americans simply did not enjoy the same rights as White Americans. One significant but overlooked area in which this was true was in where Blacks were allowed to sit on public transportation. The laws in Montgomery, a city only about 4 hours south of where I grew up, said that Black riders could sit anywhere they wished–until the front seats were needed by White citizens. That was the law and it was enforced. So, if the bus were starting to get full, and a White person boarded, Black citizens had to get out of their seats and move to the back of the bus so the White person could sit.
And that’s what this young Black woman was fighting against when she took a stand in March of 1955 and decided she wasn’t going to move, that she had the same right to the seat as any other citizen of Alabama and the United States. The police were called, and she was arrested for violating the law. Well, the truth of the matter is that is what happened, and it’s also not what happened.
You see, the decision to test the law was made by the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP). In order for the unjust law to be challenged, there had to be a court case. And, the way you achieved standing (the right to have a case tried) was to have a reason for being in court in the first place–the issue has to affect that person. And the way a person can show that the law had a negative impact on them was to be arrested and have the case heard. And that’s what happened.
Except this story ends differently that you might think. You see, the young woman who got arrested in March of 1955 for not relinquishing her seat to a White person was not quite what the NAACP was looking for in a sympathetic defendant in court and in the court of public opinion. The attorneys for the group felt strongly that she was wrong for the test case on several counts. First of all, she was single and pregnant at a time when that situation still caused a negative reaction by the public at large. Secondly, she had extremely dark skin, and that was off-putting to many White people. Finally, she was only 15. So, despite the injustice she suffered, Claudette Colvin’s case wasn’t taken up by the NAACP.
It would be 9 months later before a more suitable candidate for the lawsuit, Rosa Parks, would be arrested for the same thing.




